A new study has found that older adults who have experienced incarceration face significantly poorer physical and mental health than their peers who have never been imprisoned—even when their time behind bars occurred decades earlier. The research, published in the Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, underscores how the long shadow of incarceration extends well into later life, with implications for healthcare and social policy.
The analysis drew on data from 1,318 participants aged fifty and above who took part in the Family History of Incarceration Survey. Of these respondents, roughly one in five—around twenty-one per cent—had been incarcerated at some point in their lives. The researchers observed that formerly incarcerated older adults were disproportionately male, non-Hispanic Black or of other minority racial and ethnic backgrounds. They were also more likely to be unmarried, have a disability, and report lower income and educational attainment compared with those who had never been incarcerated. This demographic and socioeconomic profile suggests that the experience of incarceration is entangled with broader patterns of disadvantage.
Even after accounting for factors such as age, race, education, income, and marital status, prior incarceration remained a powerful predictor of poor self-reported physical health. The study revealed that those with a history of imprisonment had nearly ninety per cent higher odds of describing their health as “fair” or “poor” compared with their counterparts without such a history. Notably, this link did not diminish with time: individuals who had been incarcerated more than ten years ago reported health outcomes just as poor as those who had been released more recently. This finding suggests that the negative health effects of incarceration endure long after reintegration into society, potentially reflecting both the physical and psychological toll of prison life and the cumulative challenges faced upon re-entry.
The researchers also explored the relationship between incarceration and mental health, finding that poorer mental wellbeing among formerly incarcerated older adults could be partly explained by income and employment disparities. This indicates that the stressors associated with economic instability and limited job opportunities following incarceration may continue to erode mental health over the life course. These findings align with broader evidence linking incarceration to structural barriers such as stigma, restricted access to healthcare, and weakened social support networks—all of which can compound over time and manifest in chronic stress and illness.
The authors argue that the findings carry important implications for healthcare providers, particularly those caring for ageing populations. They suggest that clinicians consider screening patients for a history of incarceration, as this information could help identify individuals at higher risk for health problems that might otherwise go unexplained. Recognising incarceration as a social determinant of health could guide providers to connect such patients with appropriate support services and community organisations, including those specialising in re-entry assistance, mental health counselling, and disability resources.
“Mass incarceration began in 1973, so older adults have spent most of their adult lives in this era and millions have been incarcerated in the past,” said corresponding author Dr Louisa W. Holaday of the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai. “It is critical to understand how incarceration—even in the distant past—may affect the health of older adults and what we can do to improve their health.” Her statement highlights the growing urgency of addressing the lasting health consequences of incarceration as the population of formerly incarcerated older adults continues to rise. By revealing the enduring impact of imprisonment on ageing bodies and minds, the study calls attention to an often-overlooked facet of public health and social justice.
More information: Louisa W. Holaday et al, The Long Shadow of Incarceration: The Association of Incarceration History With Self-Reported Health Among Older Adults, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society. DOI: 10.1111/jgs.70069
Journal information: Journal of the American Geriatrics Society Provided by Wiley
